On September 14, 2004, “Arts & Crafts International” label released “Set Yourself on Fire”, the third Stars studio album. It was recorded 2003 – 2004, and was produced by Tom McFallm, Amy Millan, Chris Seligmanm, Pat McGee, Torquil Campbell and Evan Cranley.

Personnel:

• Amy Millan – vocals, guitar
• Chris Seligman – keyboards, French horn, string arrangements
• Torquil Campbell – vocals, trumpet, keyboards
• Evan Cranley – guitar, trombone, bass, bass synth, percussion  
• Pat McGee – drums, percussion, glockenspiel
• James Shaw – additional guitar, additional production 
• Eric Hove – saxophone
• Lana Tomlin – violin
• Rachel Moody – violin
• Markia Anthony-Shaw – viola
• Anne-Marie Leblanc – cello
• Douglas Campbell – Dad’s God voice
• Tom McFall – engineer
• Drew Malamud – engineer assistant, mastering
• Tony Hoffer – mixing
• Brett Zilahi – mastering
• Ibi Kaslik – sleeve notes

Track listing:

1. Your Ex-Lover Is Dead
2. Set Yourself on Fire
3. Ageless Beauty
4. Reunion
5. The Big Fight
6. What I’m Trying to Say
7. One More Night (Your Ex-Lover Remains Dead)
8. Sleep Tonight
9. The First Five Times
10. He Lied About Death
11. Celebration Guns
12. Soft Revolution
13. Calendar Girl